Comparing Asphalt Shingles in Southeastern PA: Pros, Cons & Costs

sam86878
Jun 9
2 min read

Asphalt shingles dominate our roofing market—from Wyomissing to Allentown—thanks to affordability, ease of installation, and style variety. At Red Patch Roofing, we focus on architectural and premium laminated shingles, since traditional 3-tab shingles are now outdated and unreliable. Here’s how today’s top asphalt options compare in cost, performance, and lifespan for Southeastern Pennsylvania homes.

Rows of textured wall tiles in brown, gray, and black hues on display under bright lighting. The setting is clean and modern.

1. Asphalt Shingle Types & Costs

Shingle Type	Installed Cost (per square*)	Warranty	Expected Lifespan
3-Tab Shingles*	$90–$120	15–25 year	15–20 years
Architectural (Dimensional)	$120–$160	25–30 year	20–30 years
Premium Laminated/Shake-Style	$150–$200	30–50 year	25–35 years

*A “square” = 100 sq ft. Costs vary by roof complexity and local labor rates. Note: Red Patch Roofing does not install 3-tab shingles—they lack the durability and warranty performance required in our climate.

2. Why We Reject 3-Tab Shingles

Shorter Lifespan: Vulnerable to curling and granule loss under UV exposure and freeze-thaw cycles.
Low Wind Resistance: Typically rated for winds under 60 mph—insufficient for Berks County storms.
Warranty Limitations: Prorated coverage offers minimal value after 5–10 years.

3. Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles

Pros:

Thick, dual-layer construction for a rich, dimensional look.
Wind warranties up to 130 mph—ideal for spring/summer thunderstorms.
Improved granule adhesion reduces early wash-off.

Cons:

20–30% higher cost than basic 3-tab.
Slightly heavier—older roofs may need minor deck reinforcement.

Brick chimney on a gray paved rooftop, casting a shadow. Green grass visible in the background, under bright sunlight.

4. Premium Laminated & Shake-Style Shingles

Pros:

Mimic cedar or slate aesthetics at lower weight.
Deep texture and shadow lines boost curb appeal.
Non-prorated warranties up to 50 years.

Cons:

Premium price point—can approach $200/sq on complex roofs.
Requires experienced installers to maintain realistic profiles.

5. Southeastern PA Climate Considerations

Freeze-Thaw Cycles: Favor dimensional or premium shingles with strong sealant strips to resist cracking.
Wind & Hail: Look for Class 3 or 4 impact ratings and wind warranties ≥ 110 mph.
UV & Heat: Choose shingles with UV-resistant granules; lighter hues reflect more solar energy, reducing attic temperatures.

6. Warranty & Installation Matters

Material vs. Workmanship: Confirm both a robust manufacturer warranty (ideally non-prorated) and a 5–10 year labor warranty from your contractor.
Certified Installers: Improper nailing patterns or flashing details are the leading causes of premature failures—always use a certified local roofer.
Permits & Inspections: All re-roofs in Wyomissing require a PA UCC Residential Building Permit. We handle submissions and scheduling for you.

Six colored rubber tile samples in black, red, gray, blue, white, and green arranged diagonally on a white background.

7. Making Your Decision

Factor	Architectural	Premium Laminated
Budget	★★★★☆	★★☆☆☆
Durability	★★★★☆	★★★★★
Aesthetics	★★★★☆	★★★★★
Wind Resistance	★★★★☆	★★★★★
Lifespan (yrs)	20–30	25–35