Why 3-Tab Shingles Are a Bad Investment (And What We Recommend Instead)

Sometimes cheaper really does mean cheaper — and nowhere is that more true than with 3-tab shingles.

At Red Patch Roofing, we get asked all the time: "Can I save money by going with 3-tab shingles?"

Our answer? You’ll save money now — and spend more later.

Here’s why we rarely recommend 3-tab shingles to Berks County homeowners — and what we install instead to protect your home (and wallet).

🏚️ What Are 3-Tab Shingles?

3-tab shingles are:

• Flat, single-layer asphalt shingles

• Have 3 “tabs” for visual separation

• Thin and lightweight

• Typically the cheapest shingle option on the market

In short: They do the job… but not for long.

🚩 Why We Don’t Recommend Them

1️⃣ Shorter Lifespan

• 3-tab: 12-18 years (often less in PA weather)

• Architectural: 20-30+ years

You’ll be replacing a 3-tab roof far sooner.

2️⃣ Poor Wind Resistance

Berks County sees plenty of storms.3-tab shingles are rated for winds around 60 mph — architectural shingles can handle 110-130+ mph.

We’ve seen whole sections of 3-tab roofs blown off after a good storm.

3️⃣ Less Curb Appeal

3-tab shingles look flat and dated. Architectural shingles:

• Thicker profile

• More shadowing

• Higher-end look

Your home will show better — and appraise better — with architectural shingles.

4️⃣ Lower Resale Value

Savvy buyers know the difference.

• A 3-tab roof screams budget job

• Architectural shingles signal quality & longevity

If you’re selling your home in the next 10 years, architectural is the smarter investment.

🏠 What We Recommend Instead

At Red Patch Roofing, we proudly install architectural asphalt shingles as our go-to choice for most residential projects.

Brands we trust:

✅ CertainTeed Landmark

✅ GAF Timberline HDZ

✅ Owens Corning Duration

Why?

• Longer lifespan

• Better weather resistance

• Superior appearance

• Better warranties

In select cases, we’ll also recommend metal roofing for homeowners who want ultimate durability.

🎖️ Final Word From Red Patch Roofing

As a veteran-owned roofing company, we believe in doing the job once — and doing it right.

We won’t cut corners with inferior products that leave you replacing your roof again in 10-12 years.

If you want honest advice and a roof built to stand the test of time, call Red Patch Roofing. We’ll help you choose the right materials — and skip the costly mistakes.